RestaurantsBoothbay Harbor

The Whale's Tale & Seafarer's Pub

The Whale's Tale & Seafarer's Pub: Seafood restaurant in Boothbay Harbor

(175)
Seafood restaurant$$$
The Whale's Tale & Seafarer's Pub
The Whale's Tale & Seafarer's Pub

Why Eat

Why The Whale's Tale & Seafarer's Pub

The Whale's Tale sits right on the water in Boothbay Harbor, slinging classic New England seafood and steaks with a full bar. The crowd's a mix of tourists and locals who've been coming back for the haddock chowder and the bay views. There's a dockside patio and live music most nights, though service can be uneven, so go in with patience.

  • Haddock chowder tastes like old Boothbay memories
  • Fried haddock sandwich among the best around
  • Bay views from nearly every table
  • Dockside patio with live music most nights

Menu

What to order

Start with the artichoke dip if you're sharing. The haddock chowder is the signature bowl, warming and rich. The fried haddock sandwich lands the way it should. Pan seared haddock with butter crumbs is solid when the kitchen's dialed in. Salmon shows up well-done on the plate. Lobster dinner comes with all the trimmings if you're splurging.

At a Glance

At a glance

Best for

Harbor views, casual seafood dinners

Price range

$$

Details

125 Atlantic Ave, Boothbay Harbor, ME 04538
(207) 633-2922
www.carouselmarina.com

Opening Times

MonClosed
Tue3:00 – 9:00 PM
Wed11:00 AM – 9:00 PM
Thu11:00 AM – 9:00 PM
Fri11:00 AM – 9:00 PM
Sat11:00 AM – 9:00 PM
SunClosed

Atmosphere

The room

Open, bright room built around the harbor view. Gets loud and boisterous once happy hour kicks in, especially on live music nights. The patio fills up fast in summer.

Best visited when you're not in a rush. Some nights the bar staff moves like they own the place. Other nights things get tangled. Oysters on the half shell, steaks, and that artichoke dip come recommended if you're going the appetizer route.

Reviews

What guests say

Guests rave about the chowder and the fried haddock sandwich as some of the best they've had. The bay views seal the deal for most. One recent visitor said the salmon "slapped." Service is hit or miss; the bar staff sometimes shines, but there've been nights when orders got dropped or delayed.

Guides

Restaurants

Nearby restaurants

All Restaurants

Hotels

Nearby hotels

$$$

Hotel

Boothbay Harbor

1 Mi to Downtown BBH Coastal Cabin

Spacious 3-bedroom cabin near downtown Boothbay Harbor with deck, yard, and fireplace. Perfect for families seeking peace and nature access.

$$$

Hotel

Boothbay Harbor

Portside

Two-bedroom beachfront cottage with sea views, private beach access, and full kitchen in Boothbay Harbor. Perfect for families and couples.

$$$

Hotel

Boothbay Harbor

Firehouse Cottage

Exceptional-rated vacation home in Boothbay Harbor with spacious living, full kitchen, outdoor grill, and dog-friendly amenities. Walk to harbor.

$$$

Hotel

Boothbay Harbor

Boothbay Harbor Beach House

Spacious four-bedroom beachfront home with private spa, full kitchen, and direct beach access in Boothbay Harbor. Perfect for families and groups.

$$$

Hotel

Boothbay Harbor

Coveside Carriage House

Private one-bedroom apartment steps from Coastal Maine Botanical Garden and Boothbay Harbor. Lake and river views, full kitchen, and welcoming hosts.

$$$

Hotel

Southport

Newagen Seaside Inn

Oceanfront resort on Southport Island with heated saltwater pool, on-site dining, and vintage games. Perfect for couples and families seeking quiet Maine coastal escape.

$$$

Hotel

Boothbay Harbor

Captain's Cottage on Atlantic

Spacious 3-bedroom vacation home steps from Boothbay Harbor shops and restaurants. Fully equipped kitchen, private entrance, ground-floor accessibility.

$$$

Hotel

Westport Island

Periwinkle Cottage

Private one-bedroom cottage on Maine's Westport Island with river views, full kitchen, and peaceful setting. Perfect for couples and solo travelers seeking solitude.

$$$

Hotel

Boothbay Harbor

Admiral's Quarters

Two-bedroom waterfront apartment in Boothbay Harbor with full kitchen, private entrance, and harbor views. Perfect for families and small groups.

$$$

Hotel

Phippsburg

Spinneys Guesthouse & Beach Cottages

Beachfront cottages and suites on Popham Beach in Phippsburg. Direct beach access, on-site restaurant, full kitchens. 9.2/10 from 45 reviews.

$$$

Hotel

Boothbay Harbor

Maine Stay

Four-bedroom vacation rental with sea views, outdoor fireplace, and full kitchen. Perfect for families and groups in Boothbay Harbor.

$$$

Hotel

Boothbay Harbor

Atlantic Gardens II

Five-bedroom beachfront home in Boothbay Harbor with full kitchen, direct beach access, and sea views. Perfect for groups and families.

All Hotels