RestaurantsYork

Anthony's Food Shop in York, Maine

Anthony's Food Shop: Convenience store in York

(920)
Convenience store$$$
Anthony's Food Shop
Anthony's Food Shop

Why Eat

Why Anthony's Food Shop

Anthony's Food Shop is a counter-serve market and bakery tucked into a gas station on the York side of things, but don't let that fool you. They're slinging wood-fired pizzas, loaded deli sandwiches, and a serious bakery operation that handles custom orders and dietary requests without making a fuss. The kind of place locals grab lunch and regulars order cakes for every holiday.

  • Homemade meatballs and fresh sauce in massive subs
  • Bakery cakes and pies for holidays and celebrations
  • Gluten-free custom orders handled without fuss
  • Wood-fired pizza from a gas station stop

Menu

What to order

Start with the meatball sub if you're hungry, or the pastrami with fries if you want it gone in two minutes. The cherry cheesecake is dependably soft and flavorful. Grab one of the oversized Italian anisette cookies for the drive. The pies and cakes for takeaway are why people phone in orders weeks ahead. Pizza's available too if you want to eat there.

At a Glance

At a glance

Best for

Lunch run, holiday orders, gas stop

Price range

$$

Details

Opening Times

Mon6:00 AM – 9:00 PM
Tue6:00 AM – 9:00 PM
Wed6:00 AM – 9:00 PM
Thu6:00 AM – 9:00 PM
Fri6:00 AM – 9:00 PM
Sat6:00 AM – 9:00 PM
Sun6:00 AM – 9:00 PM

Atmosphere

The room

Counter service, casual, quick. It's a gas station food stop, so you're in and out or ordering ahead for pickup.

The meatball subs come with homemade meatballs the size of softballs. The pastrami is cooked right. The cherry cheesecake is soft and tastes like someone's aunt made it. Tammy, one of the bakers, takes special orders seriously, including gluten-free custard work that fools the whole table. You can order online or call and she'll answer your questions.

Reviews

What guests say

People drive back to York specifically for the cakes and pies. One guest said the cherry cheesecake reminded them of homemade ones from childhood. Regulars order everything from custom gluten-free Thanksgiving pies to Italian cookies for the beach. The portions are generous and the staff works hard to get orders right.

Location and nearby

Guides

Verified details

Anthony's Food Shop is listed in York, Maine, as a bakery. Fort McClary State Historic Site is 6.0 miles from Anthony's Food Shop by straight-line calculation. The coordinate-based measurement for Anthony's Food Shop is 8.9 miles to Vaughan Woods Memorial State Park. The contact number is 207-363-2322. The recorded hours for Anthony's Food Shop are Monday 06:00 to 21:00; Tuesday 06:00 to 21:00; Wednesday 06:00 to 21:00; Thursday 06:00 to 21:00; Friday 06:00 to 21:00; Saturday 06:00 to 21:00; Sunday 06:00 to 21:00. Anthony's Food Shop publishes business information at anthonysfoodshop.com.

Visit details

Official site
anthonysfoodshop.com
Property type
Market & Bakery
Hours by day
Monday6 AM–9 PMTuesday6 AM–9 PMWednesday6 AM–9 PMThursday6 AM–9 PMFriday6 AM–9 PMSaturday6 AM–9 PMSunday6 AM–9 PM

Sources (checked 2026-09-16)

Restaurants

Nearby restaurants

All Restaurants

Hotels

Nearby hotels

Albracca

$$$

Hotel

York

Albracca

Exceptional B&B in York Harbor with spacious rooms, gourmet breakfasts, and attentive hosts. Walking distance to York Harbor Beach. 9.7/10 rating.

ViewPoint Hotel

$$$

Hotel

York

ViewPoint Hotel

Modern suites with Nubble lighthouse views, heated saltwater pool, spa, and sauna in York. Couples rate it 9.9/10. Book direct.

Dockside Guest Quarters

$$$

Hotel

York

Dockside Guest Quarters

Waterfront inn on York Harbor with sea views, homemade breakfast, and quiet grounds. Couple-friendly with bikes, restaurant, and marina access.

Sunrise Motel

$$$

Hotel

York

Sunrise Motel

Beachfront motel on Long Sands Beach with private balconies, kitchenettes, and stunning ocean views. Clean, friendly, and steps from the sand.

Coastal Gem

$$$

Hotel

York

Coastal Gem

Four-bedroom vacation home steps from Long Sands Beach in York. Perfect for families and group getaways with full kitchen and outdoor space.

Seafoam Dreams

$$$

Hotel

York

Seafoam Dreams

Spacious two-bedroom apartment steps from Long Sands Beach in York. Full kitchen, bright interiors, and friendly hosts. Perfect for families and groups.

Little Cottage

$$$

Hotel

York

Little Cottage

Two- and three-bedroom cottages steps from Long Sands Beach in York, Maine. Fully equipped kitchens, grills, and quiet neighborhood setting ideal for families.

Microtel Inn & Suites York

$$$

Hotel

York

Microtel Inn & Suites York

Budget-friendly hotel in York, Maine with heated indoor pool, free breakfast, and free parking. Great base for **Short Sands Beach** and outlet shopping.

The Lighthouse Inn & Suites

$$$

Hotel

York Beach

The Lighthouse Inn & Suites

Steps from Long Sands Beach in York Beach. Pool, hot tub, and walkable to Nubble Lighthouse. Free parking and WiFi. 7.7/10 from 422 guests.

Best Western York Inn

$$$

Hotel

York

Best Western York Inn

3-star hotel in York with indoor pool, free breakfast, and free parking. 10 minutes from York Beach. 7.7/10 rating.

Shimmering Seaview

$$$

Hotel

York

Shimmering Seaview

Two-bedroom apartment steps from Long Sands Beach in York. Full kitchen, sea views, private entrance. Perfect for couples and families. 9.7/10 guest rating.

The Cottage at Long Sands

$$$

Hotel

York

The Cottage at Long Sands

Four-bedroom beachfront vacation home steps from Long Sands Beach in York. Fully equipped kitchen, outdoor spaces, and family-friendly amenities.

All Hotels