Clay Hill Farm in York, Maine

Clay Hill Farm sits on a sprawling property outside York where you can eat inside a proper dining room or venture into heated igloos scattered across the grounds. The kitchen does classic American food: filet mignon, seafood, cheesy grits. It's a destination spot, especially for anniversaries and special occasions, though the experience can be uneven depending on the night.

• Award-winning lobster bisque you can buy to go.
• Heated igloos with stars and twinkling lights overhead.
• Filet mignon cooked exactly how you order it.
• Walking trails and wooded grounds worth arriving early for.

Start with the lobster bisque, which is legitimately worth the hype and comes in quarts if you're smitten. Filet mignon is the house backbone, and it arrives cooked precisely to temp. The cheesy grits are worth their real estate on the plate. Fresh seafood rotates with the season. For dessert, give them a heads-up if you're celebrating something, it matters.

The dining room is warm and nostalgic. The igloos are the real scene: intimate, lit with strings of lights, and quiet enough to hear each other. The wooded grounds feel removed from York proper.

The food is straightforward and well-executed when it lands. The lobster bisque is award-winning for a reason, and people buy it by the quart to take home. Filet arrives cooked to order, sides like cheesy grits hold their own. Portions read smaller than some expect for the price point, and cocktail timing can lag.

Guests rave about igloo anniversaries, calling them magical and romantic. The award-winning bisque inspires people to stock their freezers. One recent visitor praised the filet and grits cooked to perfection. Service gets mixed reviews: some nights the team is attentive and goes above and beyond; other nights, timing slips and little touches like birthday candles get missed.